All
Cases double in NHS trust death and injury investigation
Cases double in NHS trust
Cases double in NHS trust death and injury investigation
Investigation Expands Amid Growing Concerns
Sussex Police has significantly expanded its probe into preventable deaths and serious injuries at University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust. What began with 105 cases in 2023 has now more than doubled to over 200.
The increase comes as more families have contacted authorities with allegations of substandard care. The investigation focuses on treatment provided between 2015 and 2021, primarily in neurosurgery and general surgery departments.
Concerns include at least 40 deaths that may have been avoidable. Police are examining potential offences such as gross negligence manslaughter and corporate manslaughter.
Background on the Trust and Initial Probe
University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust operates several hospitals, including the Royal Sussex County Hospital in Brighton. Previous BBC investigations highlighted serious issues within the trust's neurosurgery unit.
Whistleblowers raised alarms about unnecessary patient deaths, maiming, and a reported "gang culture" among some staff. A Royal College of Surgeons review identified a "culture of fear" and recommended leadership changes.
The police investigation launched in 2023 after these whistleblower concerns. It remains active and at an early stage, with no suspects named yet.
Key Departments and Alleged Harm
The majority of cases involve neurosurgery, where delays in care, training shortfalls, and high mortality rates have been alleged. General surgery cases also feature prominently in the expanded review.
Medical experts are now assessing each case to determine if standards of care were breached. This process is expected to conclude in early 2025.
The trust has faced additional scrutiny, including losing a legal challenge to block document disclosure in employment tribunals related to staff concerns.
Example: Surgeon Marc Lamah's Private Case
While not part of the police investigation (as it occurred in 2024), the case of Wendy Gibbs illustrates ongoing worries. The 80-year-old underwent pelvic prolapse repair by surgeon Marc Lamah at a Nuffield Health hospital in Brighton.
During the procedure, her bowel was snipped, leading to undetected bleeding, sepsis, emergency surgery, and a permanent stoma. Gibbs described feeling betrayed and suffering lasting trauma.
A former Nuffield director noted high complication rates linked to Lamah, with one-third of his patients experiencing moderate harm events over a year.
Categories: Medical Negligence, NHS Investigations, Patient Safety, Neurosurgery Concerns
Keywords: University Hospitals Sussex, Sussex Police investigation, preventable deaths, neurosurgery failings, Marc Lamah, Wendy Gibbs, gross negligence, Royal Sussex County Hospital
Case Example: Stephen Coles' Death
Stephen Coles, aged 66, died in 2021 after neurosurgeon Carl Hardwidge removed a brain tumour. Post-operative cranial nerve damage prevented swallowing, leading to pneumonia and death after prolonged hospital stay.
An inquest raised no concerns, but a neurological expert later assessed the death as avoidable. The expert criticised the lack of a tracheostomy to protect the airway, stating responsibility lay with the operating surgeon.
Hardwidge's care has faced questions in at least three other cases. His sister, Julie Rhodes, expressed frustration over unanswered questions from the inquest.
Trust's Official Position and Improvements
The trust stated it is fully cooperating with Sussex Police. It emphasised that patient safety remains a priority and that action is taken on any evidence of poor care.
A spokesperson acknowledged challenges in neurosurgery since 2012, including longer waits for care, and offered sincere apologies. Chief executive George Findlay noted improvements under new leadership since 2017 but admitted much work remains.
The trust audited surgeon Marc Lamah's NHS outcomes, finding them within national expected ranges. It continues to support staff and patients amid the ongoing review.
Broader Context and Family Impact
The doubling of cases reflects growing public willingness to come forward. Families seek accountability for what they believe were preventable harms in a strained system.
Previous reports highlighted whistleblower fears, delayed interventions, and systemic issues. The investigation underscores the need for robust oversight in complex surgical departments.
With medical reviews ongoing into 2025, the probe could lead to charges if evidence supports criminal thresholds. It highlights persistent challenges in maintaining safe, high-quality care.
Implications for NHS Accountability
This expansion signals heightened scrutiny of historical care at the trust. It may prompt wider reviews of surgical governance and whistleblower protections across the NHS.
Experts stress the importance of timely expert assessments and cultural change to rebuild trust. Families continue to push for transparency and learning from past incidents.
The case serves as a reminder of the human cost when standards fall short. Ongoing cooperation between police, trust, and regulators will be key to resolution.
Categories: Medical Negligence, NHS Investigations, Patient Safety, Neurosurgery Concerns
Keywords: University Hospitals Sussex, Sussex Police investigation, preventable deaths, neurosurgery failings, Marc Lamah, Wendy Gibbs, gross negligence, Royal Sussex County Hospital, Carl Hardwidge
Medical Disclaimer
Medical Disclaimer: You understand that any information and content, such as text, graphics, and images, found within our Website is for general educational, entertainment, and informational purposes only.
You understand that such information is not intended nor otherwise implied to be medical advice or a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.(Case Study or News article)
Apply For Jobs Here
Apply For Jobs Here
Trump tells BBC that King’s visit could ‘absolutely’ help repair relations with UK
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.
Hello world!
Influencer dies days after being hit by car in Soho
Man uses car to raise awareness of mental health
Power faults stop bus gate cameras catching cars
China car giant BYD says it can thrive without US
Trump tells BBC that King’s visit could ‘absolutely’ help repair relations with UK
What you need to know as Tower Hamlets heads into mayor’s election*
Manchester City History*
What you need to know as Newham heads into mayor’s election*
What you need to know as Lewisham heads into mayor’s election*
What you need to know as Hackney heads into mayor’s election*
